Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Gay Marriage and the Law

I grew up in Utah.  I am a Mormon.  I believe in God, and I believe God commands us that we should not have sexual relations outside of marriage.  I believe God wants marriage within the church to be exclusively reserved for unions between one man and one woman.  I also believe that we are to love all of God's children to the best of our ability, and that we will be judged by how we choose to cast our stones.

I would ask anyone who reads this to refrain from inferring any of my other beliefs.

The issue of marriage between two homosexuals is extremely controversial.  That's because it deals with sex, right?  I assume that far more people will be judged harshly for their greed, intolerance, wrath, adultery, dishonesty, and selfishness than for their gay relationships.   But I don't see a proposition 8 type fight over banning selfishness.   I also assume that the judgment for promiscuity and fornication will be similar to the judgment for gay sex.  I wouldn't be at all surprised if Barney Stinson were judged more harshly for his heterosexual relationships than Neil Patrick Harris will for his homosexual relationship.  But I don't see a proposition 8 type fight over banning fornication.

The Gay-Marriage battle-waters are murky.  It's unclear exactly what the strategy is or what benefits the warriors intend to reap.  

The waters are murky because:

Gay sex is legal.
Fornication is legal (or laws against it are not enforced)
Adoption by one gay person is legal
Contracts between Gays are legal
Gays can have power of attorney for one another
Gays can live together
Gays can jointly own property
Gays can devise all of their property to another gay person in their last will and testament.

Do members of the anti-gay-marriage crowd have a problem with any of those items listed above?  If so, why not legislate against it?  Why not have a "don't-ask don't-tell" policy for property owners.  "You may share real estate so long as you don't tell anyone you are gay."   Why did Lawrence v. Texas effectively end the public debate over sexual privacy?   I don't hear calls for a proposed constitutional amendment making gay sex illegal.

It seems clear that for many things, like fornication, LDS church members and others of similar faith have no problem separating morality and eternal law from the legislative and judicial system here on earth.    In the past, some Christians have sought to enforce laws against unmarried cohabitation.  They have tried to force unwed mothers to get married or give up the baby.  They have enacted legislation allowing police to investigate and prosecute individuals accused of sodomy.  

But in this day and age, the majority of the country chooses to determine what is "right" and "wrong" independently of what is "legal."    It is possible to believe that two unwed partners should not have kids together without making a law against it.  It's possible to believe that men should not have sexual relations with other men without making a law against it.

Currently none of the sanctity of marriage laws are effectively stopping any actual behavior.  Gays still live together, love each other, are intimate, adopt kids, start businesses, own property, and care for one another in the hospital, yet the line in the sand has been drawn at the "symbol" of marriage.   The concern must be over the acknowledgement by society that gay unions are equal to straight marriage, and I don't see anything in the constitution that gives marriage a higher status than any other type of relationship.  

I believe everyone is entitled to their opinion, and that personal opinions about morality and spirituality can and should be involved in political discussions.  But the current debate has forced many believers to engage in straw-man arguments, put forth faulty logic, and cherry pick misleading data.  That type of justification strategy undermines the credibility of its source.  I don't think anyone should be afraid to stand up and say, "I believe God wants us to pass the following law: _________" yet so many engage in "logical" debates about things that are of a spiritual nature.     If you want to convince the voters that they should follow God's will, discuss God and Jesus Christ with them, not Caesar.







 

Thursday, November 15, 2012

iPhone 5 vs. Samsung Galaxy Note 2: My Switch from iOS 6 to Android 4.1

In my past, I've had stints as an Apple hater, an Apple fan boy, and an "I'm so bored of my iPhone" guy.
I work on a Lenovo PC, my home computer is a 2009 Macbook Pro 13.3'', and I've owned an iPhone 3gs and an iPhone 4.  I've also used my wife's iPhone 4s extensively.

I finally decided to switch from my three year love-affair with iPhone to a Samsung Galaxy Note 2 (after months of research, finally deciding on the Nexus 4, the Nexus 4 selling out, and absolutely loving the Galaxy Note 2 at the AT&T store.)

In order to review my transition and the Galaxy Note 2, I will be comparing the Galaxy Note 2 to the iPhone 5 and iPhone 4s.

Let's get to it.

Size & Weight

Handling the Phone
This is really the first big issue, with a massive 5.5'' screen, the Note 2 is imposing.  The size difference between the 4s and the Note 2 is incredible.  I showed the Note 2 to my boss the day I purchased it and he just started laughing.  A friend asked me if I planned to avoid jeans for the next two years.

The phone fits easily into my dress-pants pocket, and has no problem slipping in my non-skinny jeans pocket.  I like to store the phone in my dress-shirt pocket as well (which is stupid) and the top of the phone pokes out by about an inch.

I have average-sized hands:  with my hand fully extended the distance from the end of my thumb to the end of my pinky finger is just about 9 inches, and the distance from the end of my thumb to the end of my index finger is about 7.5 inches.

I was annoyed by the phone dimensions at first.  The keyboard pops up too far from the email send button for my thumb to reach both without shifting my hand, and texting with one hand provides a "i'm going to drop this thing" sensation.

That said, I adjusted to the size in about 24 hours.  The phone is so thin, and the design makes it easy to hold.  I can easily grasp the phone to read articles without getting worn out (like when you hold the corner of an iPad for too long).  I estimate I can easily do 85% of my normal activities without needing the second hand.

That said, think it is important to buy a case for this thing.  I've treated it like a newborn baby, and I'm in constant fear of dropping it onto its massive face.  My case should arrive in a couple days.

Viewing the Display
The size of the display is amazing for daily use.  I was afraid it wouldn't be big enough to use like a tablet, and that the size would be cumbersome for a phone.  I was wrong.   In landscape mode, I can see a list of emails with a preview window (like on outlook or gmail)  I can open two applications at the same time, reading a webpage while typing information into a note or email.  I can comfortably view full webpages without resorting to the web version, and movies and TV look amazing.  The Note 2 is by no means a TV replacement (some prefer to watch movies on their close-to-face iPads over smallish TVs), but it's big enough to function as a "second screen" to interact with TV programming.

The iPhone 4s and iPhone 5 have beautiful displays (more on that next) and I think the 3.5 and 4 inch screens are ideal for email, texting, and facebooking.   But the Note 2 clearly dominates in web browsing, viewing pinterest and twitter, and using apps like Pulse News, the calendar, and task lists.

The size isn't for everyone, but I use my phone as a tablet 85% of the time and as a phone 15%. For me, this is a no brainer.  (I also have a huge head, so it doesn't look as ridiculous when I make calls on it.  You small-headed people should really consider this, as you will look foolish).

Advantage: Note 2

Screen Quality

After purchasing the note 2, I viewed the display as I walked out to my car.  I've read hundreds of reviews on AMOLED and LCD phone screens, and many of them argue that the iPhone (LCD) is much brighter, better in the sun, and has truer color reproduction.  These arguments are absolutely right.

If you plan on reading outdoors a lot, the Note 2 pales in comparison to the iPhone 5.  The Note 2's screen isn't terribly reflective, but it just isn't that bright, and the whites are more gray.   Both the iPhone and the Note 2 have great black levels, but the Note 2 AMOLED has hyper-real coloring. (This improves when you select "movie" mode).  The pixel density of the Note 2 is substantially lower than the iPhone and Galaxy S3 (and pretty much every other new phone) because it's so huge.  This is noticeable, but it isn't a big issue especially if you hold the phone further from your face.  

Text and graphics look sharp on the Note 2, and I have no concerns with the pixel density on most things, but it's clearly not as sharp as the iPhone.  ( the "netflix" on the netflix app icon is kind of blurred).

While I see this as a big advantage for the iPhone, the Note 2's screen is still fantastic.  Most people after an hour or so of use will not have any concerns about it.

Large Advantage: iPhone 5 (and 4s and 4, but the Note 2 decimates the 3gs)

Build Quality

Going in, I had some major concerns about the "plasticky" feel of the Note 2 and S 3.  However, I've been pleasantly surprised.  The phone is solid in my hand, and I can hold any corner without feeling any cracking or settling, even though the pack of the phone is very flexible.   The screen is made out of the high quality Corning Gorilla Glass 2, and the border of the phone is solid.  However, some may have concerns with the plastic feel of the back plate, and others may worry that the massive surface area is prone to breaking.  I won't be drop testing this phone, but it is obvious the iPhone wins in build quality.  The 4s could kill a burglar, and the iPhone 5 seems super light and super strong.

Still, I don't think this will matter to most people.  The main issue in the feel of the phone is the size, not the build quality.  If you can get use to the size, you won't have concerns about quality.

Advantage: iPhone 5

Operating System
As a convert to Android, I could go on and on about this.  I absolutely love Jellybean 4.1.  There are many features that I love, and iOS 6 seems very old fashioned.  Of course, some differences and glitches really bother me, but perhaps I'll have another post on this.

I think the availability of widgets is overplayed by some google fanboys, but the ability to have one screen dedicated to my email is HUGE for me, as emailing is the primary reason I have a smart phone.  I love the endless options for phone settings, and the huge amount of control I have.

This really comes down to preference, but I personally see many limitations in iOS that I don't see in Android 4.1.  Also, Android makes it so easy to set your cursor when you are typing, something that is incredibly frustrating in iOS.  So far, the Note 2 has been able to accomplish every task I want it to accomplish, and each and every App I've grown to love is available through the google store.

A surprising development is how all of my favorite apps look better on Android.  I'm flabbergasted  to be honest.  Pulse news, Netflix, email, calendar, all the google apps, pinterest, facebook, twitter, stumble upon and more are all more accessible and beautiful on Android.  It's hard for me to separate the screen size from the app quality, as it does make a difference, but all things being equal, I think the android designs are superior.

The internet browser on Android decimates mobile Safari.  But that's just my opinion.

I will note that the responsiveness of the touch screen is better in iOS, but the Note 2 is very good, and a huge improvement over android phones from 2 years ago.

Advantage: Note 2

Speed

Both phones are fast... really fast.  The Note 2 is freaky.  As long as my internet connection can keep up, stumble upon response almost instantaneously.  Switching between apps is faster than my new office computer.  There have been a few hiccups here and there, but the Note 2's quad core processor is amazing.

The Note 2. does run a little hot when you watch netflix, but I've found this to be the case with most phones and computers.

Advantage: Tie


Battery Life

All I can say in this category is that I worked the Note 2 very hard on the second day. The battery in this thing is huge (3100) which is good, since the screen is huge.  A full hour playing a graphics intense game (for testing, of course) a full episode of Breaking Bad on netflix, web browsing much of the day, emailing all day, even some draw something (that app sucks battery like crazy), and the note 2 made it from 7:00 AM to Midnight (5% battery left).  I haven't used it as intensely today, but it is at 94% after being unplugged for 6 hours.

This clearly beats my wife's iPhone 4s, but most benchmarks show it having similar performance to the iPhone 4.

Advantage: This is probably a tie for most people and it will change depending on your use.  Both phones tend to make it a full day with no problem.

Speakers

The back speaker on the Note 2 has better volume and sound than the iPhone 4s.  I haven't used the iPhone 5 enough to know how it compares.

It is a phone speaker, of course, so it isn't a bose sound system, but the volume and quality were good even when I turned the volume up on Netflix.

Advantage: Probably the Note 2, as iPhones don't have great speakers in their tiny compact bodies. But I don't know for sure.

Calling

This is an area that clearly dominates the iPhone.  The sound quality of the Note 2 took me back to my old home-phone days.  the iPhone is really a terrible phone (but a fantastic device).  The Note 2 call quality was as good as I'd ever need, but I'm sure there are better performing phones out there.

Advantage: Note 2

Other Features

The Note 2 has S Pen and a stylus.  I'm still not sure how much I'll use this, but it is very cool.  It follows my handwriting well with little to no lag, and playing draw something is a blast.  The text recognition is very good, but I have trouble getting spaces in the right place.  I think this is a luxury that most people won't really care about, but it is cool and the stylus fits snugly in the phone.  I almost don't notice it.

Siri vs. S Voice:   I don't really use these features, but I think S Voice is a passable competitor.  I don't think this should go into your decision making.  Both are equally awesome and equally crappy.

Miscellaneous Hardware

I'm not a hardware expert, but it's hard to beat this Note 2 in terms of guts.  The Quad Core processor and 2GB of Ram future-proof this device for a while.

The Note 2 is limited by the 16GB of internal storage, which is more like 11GB after all the samsung and att crap is loaded.

The iPhone has more options with internal memory, but you can pick up a 64GB SD card for the Note 2 for around 50 bucks.  That's a ton more storage with little trouble.  I don't think I'll really need it, but it's nice.



SAMSUNG GALAXY NOTE II

Pros:
The big screen is really a huge benefit and relatively easy to get used to
Incredibly fast
Great features in Android 4.1
Great Battery Life
Expandable storage

Cons:
Screen isn't that bright
Touch screen is less responsive than iPhone
It might be too large for some one-handed use
It's $299 with a contract.

Friday, July 13, 2012

Dream Team vs. Dreaming Team?

Kobe is getting flack for expressing confidence in his 2012 olympic team.  People are mostly pissed because it's Kobe, and because he said the dream team was old.   The dream team wasn't that old, but Magic had been out of the league for a year and Bird was having significant back problems.

I don't know that the 1992 dream team would destroy the 2012 USA Basketball team.  I'm just surprised that everyone else thinks they know that.

Let's go through the stats.

I think 1992 would win by six points or so, mostly because Ewing, Robinson, and Malone would dominate the paint.

STARTING FIVE: STATS FROM THE YEAR BEFORE THEIR RESPECTIVE OLYMPIC GAMES.

CENTER  (Moderate Advantage 1992 = 10 to 8)

Tyson Chandler
11.3 PPG, .679 FG%, .689 FT %, 9.9 Reb/gm, 1.4 Blks per game.

Patrick Ewing
24 PPG, .522 FG%, .738 FT%, 11.3 Reb/gm, 3 Blks per game


POWER FORWARD  (Virtual Tie = 10 to 10)


Kevin Durant  6' 9", 235 lbs
28 PPG, .496 FG%, .860 FT %, 8 Reb/gm, 1.2 Blks/game, 3.5 Assists/gm

Karl Malone  6'9", 259 lbs
29 PPG, .527 FG%, .770 FT%, 11.8 Reb/gm, 1 Blks/game, 3.3 Assists/gm

SMALL FORWARD (Moderate Advantage 2012 = 8 to 10)

Lebron James 6' 8", 250 lbs
27.1 PPG, .531 FG%, .746 FT %, 7.9 Reb/gm, .8 Blks/game, 6.2 Assists/gm

Larry Bird 6'9", 220 lbs
20.2 PPG, .466 FG%, .926 FT%, 9.6 Reb/gm, .84 Blks/game, 6.8 Assists/gm

SHOOTING GUARD (Slight to Moderate Advantage 1992 = 10 to 8.5)

Kobe Bryant 6' 6", 205 lbs
27.9 PPG, .430 FG%, .845 FT %, 5.4 Reb/gm, .3 Blks/game, 4.6 Assists/gm

Michael Jordan 6'6", 216 lbs
30.1 PPG, .519 FG%, .832 FT%, 6.4 Reb/gm, .9 Blks/game, 6.1 Assists/gm

POINT GUARD (Tie because Magic Hadn't Played = 10 to 10)

Deron Williams 6' 3", 209 lbs
21 PPG, .407 FG%, .843 FT %, 3.3 Reb/gm, .4 Blks/game, 8.7 Assists/gm

Magic Johnson 6'9", 220 lbs  (Didn't play in 1992 so these are from 1991)
19.4 PPG, .477 FG%, .906 FT%, 6.9 Reb/gm, .2 Blks/game, 12.5 Assists/gm






BENCH: STATS FROM THE YEAR BEFORE THEIR RESPECTIVE OLYMPIC GAMES.

CENTER  (Substantial Advantage 1992 = 10 to 6)

David Robinson
23.2 PPG, .551 FG%, .701 FT %, 12.2 Reb/gm, 4.5 Blks per game.



POWER FORWARD  (Virtual Tie = 10 to 10)

Kevin Love  6'10", 260 lbs
26 PPG, .448 FG%, .824 FT %, 13.3 Reb/gm, .5 Blks/game, 2.0 Assists/gm

Anthony Davis  6'11", 220 lbs
No Stats


Christian Laettner  6'11", 235 lbs
No Stats

Charles Barkley  6'6", 250 lbs
25.6 PPG, .520 FG%, .765 FT %, 12.2 Reb/gm, 1 Blks/game, 5.1 Assists/gm





SMALL FORWARD (Slight advantage 1992 = 10 to 9)

Carmello Anthony  6'8", 230 lbs
22.6 PPG, .430 FG%, .804 FT%, 6.3 Reb/gm, .4 Blks/game, 3.6 Assists/gm

Andre Iguodala, 6'6'', 207

12.4 PPG, .454 FG%, .617 FT%, 6.1 Reb/gm, .5 Blks/game, 5.5 Assists/gm



Scottie Pippen 6'7", 210 lbs
18.6 PPG, .473 FG%, .663 FT%, 7.7 Reb/gm, .9 Blks/game, 6.3 Assists/gm

Chris Mullin 6'7", 215 lbs
25.6 PPG, .524 FG%, .833 FT%, 5.6 Reb/gm, .8 Blks/game, 3.5 Assists/gm





SHOOTING GUARD (Slight to Moderate Advantage 1992 = 10 to 8.5)

James Harden 6'5'', 220 lbs
16.8 PPG, .491 FG%, .846 FT %, 4.1 Reb/gm, .3 Blks/game, 3.7 Assists/gm

Clyde Drexler 6'7", 220 lbs
25 PPG, .470 FG%, .794 FT%, 6.6 Reb/gm, .9 Blks/game, 6.7 Assists/gm

POINT GUARD  (Moderate Advantage 2012 = 8 to 10)

Russell Westbrook 6' 3", 187 lbs
23.6 PPG, .457 FG%, .823 FT %, 4.6 Reb/gm, .3 Blks/game, 5.5 Assists/gm

Chris Paul 6' 0", 183 lbs
19.8 PPG, .478 FG%, .861 FT %, 3.6 Reb/gm, .1 Blks/game, 9.1 Assists/gm


John Stockton 6'1", 175 lbs  (Didn't play in 1992 so these are from 1991)
15.8 PPG, .482 FG%, .842 FT%, 3.3 Reb/gm, .3 Blks/game, 13.7 Assists/gm






If you assume all of these players are at their best I don't think it's unreasonable to say 2012 would put up a fight.  Jordan wouldn't really dominate Kobe if both players were on in the clutch.  (Kobe was pretty clutch in the last olympics.)  Lebron would have a significant advantage over Bird which he could exploit over and over (or maybe Bird would guard Durant, which would lead to a similar result). Magic could use his size to exploit Williams, Paul, and Westbrook, but Magic was a bit unpredictable in 1992.  Stockton is one of the best point guards ever, but he worked best with a team he was familiar with. I think Paul and Westbrook could have frustrated him.  I love Malone, but I don't think he'd have much of an advantage over over Durant and/or Lebron (with some Kevin Love and Anthony Davis Mixed in.)

I think 2012 would have a bit of a speed advantage, while 1992 would have a significant size advantage.  The Admiral would make the difference.  Chandler and Anthony Davis would face an onslaught from Ewing, Robinson, Malone, Barkley and Laettner. 

Still, if Kobe, Durant, Lebron, and Carmello are on.... they would be tough to guard.




Thursday, June 14, 2012

The Problem with Sids Statistics: Truthiness

A sleep deprived mother wakes to the sound of a soft cry at 5:15 AM.  This will be the 8th time in three hours that the mother will get up and re position her baby's binky.  She just can't do this anymore.  She walks in to the baby's room and notices that the child is suffering from some gas-related discomfort.  Desperate, the Mother moves the baby onto her tummy.  The baby moves into a little ball position and gets rid of some gas, and then falls fast asleep for two hours.  Two...precious....hours.

Well according to many doctors and websites, stomach sleepers are twice as likely to die from Sudden Infant Death Syndrome ("SIDS").

Unfortunately, this is a classic example of statistical bologna.  Look, I'm not suggesting that you shouldn't take precautions, or that it's a good idea to go against the American Academy of Pediatrics recommendation that "back is best."  I am saying that the way the statistics are presented is bull crap.

If you look at the data, the "double risk" conclusion is based on the change in SIDS deaths after the "back to sleep" campaign in 1992-1994.  SIDS rates dropped from approximately 14 deaths per 10,000 babies in 1992  down to just under 7 deaths per 10,000 babies now.   Yeah, that's a 50% reduction all right!  And that reduction is enough evidence for the CDC, AAP, and NHI to say that you should NEVER let your child sleep on her stomach, not even for a nap, unless she has a significant digestive disorder and your doctor tells you to try stomach sleeping.

A few things:

1: While the reduction in SIDS did accelerate after "back to sleep," the SIDS rate was already coming down. The overall infant mortality rate was also coming down quickly before the back to sleep campaign.

2:  The SIDS rate continued to decrease long after the "back to sleep" campaign was commonly known among health care practitioners and new moms.

3: A massive campaign against SIDS would have increased SIDS awareness, and other preventative measures were surely taken.

4: Doctors and researchers admit they can only show a strong correlation, not a causal connection, between stomach sleeping and SIDS.

5: Not all 50% reductions are equal.   If the rate changed from 22%  to 11%, that would be an incredibly significant 50% reduction.  In this case, the change was from 0.14% to 0.07% where at least half of the reduction occurred more than 4 years after the campaign.

6:  SIDS is the third leading cause of infant death after congenital defects and low birth weight.  Also, low birth weight increases the likelihood of a SIDS death, but I'm not sure which cause gets blamed.

Apparently more kids die of SIDS in the winter, even though colder room temperatures might prevent temperatures.  Heaters working too well?
Black children are far more likely than white children to die of sids, and boys are more likely than girls.
A pacifier might also reduce the risk of SIDS.
SIDS rates are higher when babies sleep in the parental bed, but lower when babies sleep in a separate bed in a different room.
One theory suggests that SIDS is caused by deep sleep and brains that fail to wake babies up when oxygen levels dip too low.

When you read the SIDS sources, common words include "might" "may" and "possibly."   I read an article by one doctor who said, "if we knew what caused SIDS, we wouldn't call it SIDS."   Finally, some researchers think that a large part of the SIDS rate reduction was due to reclassification of suffocation deaths which used to be considered SIDS.

Again, it's better safe than sorry, but SIDS is so terrifying that we are particularly sensitive to the risks.

We aren't as sensitive in other areas.  For example, my wife could conceivably never take our children out of the house.  The risk of dying in a car accident is infinitely larger if you ride in cars than if you don't.
My wife could refuse to take my toddler to church or allow her to go to nursery with her little friends in order to prevent my toddler from catching something and infecting our infant.
My wife could decide to not allow anyone without a whooping cough vaccine to enter our home.

I sincerely doubt a Doctor would recommend that a mother do any of those things.  Is that simply because SIDS is far more likely to result in death?  Probably, but I think the manipulation of the statistics happens because SIDS is terrifying.  It's so terrifying to me, that even if there were bull crap statistics that suggested I should wake up my baby every 30 minutes (which would almost certainly  limit SIDS risk) I would consider it... until I fell into a sleep deprivation coma.

Thoughts?

Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Public Enemy #1: Procrastination


(Disclaimer, this post was written during "free time," when I probably should have been exercising or sleeping)

I think the real disease attacking the work ethic of young adults and children today isn't specifically video games, movies, social networking, texting, or other time wasters--these are just the symptoms--the problem is procrastination.  Why do young people procrastinate so much?  Yeah, I'm going to blame schools.

I typically think of procrastination as putting something off for tomorrow.  Failure to act immediately, driven by the existence of extra time.   The dictionary defines "procrastinate" as a verb meaning to defer action or put off till another time.  I think it's more than that.

As a Mormon missionary in Taiwan, I always worked with a partner, or "companion" as we called them.  Each week, my companion and I had a designated time set aside to plan for the rest of the week, and we were instructed to make goals for the week, for each day, and for each hour of the day.  We were also instructed to plan out every 15 minute block of time with separate strategies on how to meet those goals.  This included planning for travel time, eating, bathroom breaks, and everything else you could think of.

I discovered quicky that I was either poor at planning or implementation, because my companions and I were constantly modifying our plans (or ignoring them) in favor of doing something else.  Often, once we failed to adhere to our planning for an hour or two, the whole day's plan would go out the window.

My plans weren't usually derailed by external forces like, say, getting hit by a car (happened twice).  In most cases my companion and I either lost focus (33% of the time) or we made deliberate changes.  I never considered it at the time, but I subconsciously valued planning in the moment over planning for the long term even though I truly believed that goal oriented, long-term planning was more effective.  That's procrastination.  You make a goal, you determine how to achieve that goal, and you do something else.

This wasn't disruptive during my mission, because the drop in efficiency was not substantial.  Rather than knocking on doors to spread a message, we would talk to people coming out of the subway station.  The change could have been due to anything from laziness to a strategy shift based on new information, but it was still procrastination.  Fortunately, I didn't have distractions to fill the gaps

However, in academic and professional areas, procrastination can be incredibly harmful, even debilitating.  I can't tell you how many bank tellers I worked with who would spend time cleaning out their printers with canned air in lieu of handling mundane paperwork.  I've been tempted hundreds of times to clean up my desk and work area in the name of efficiency when I still have a long to-do list staring me in the face. In those times when I've given in, I even broke out the furniture polish and canned air.

There's no way I would claim that the task of polishing my desk is more important than urgent work for a client.  There's also no way that polishing my desk during a busy time will help me reach the goals I have set for myself.  Nevertheless, when a person believes there is time available in the future for a task, then it becomes harder to balance what tasks are more important.

In other words, if I was planning for an entire week, I would separate tasks into categories: (Covey Matrix)

1: Urgent & Important  (Goal-related activities with pending deadlines)
2: Non-Urgent & Important  (Goal-related activities with no deadlines, like planning or education)
3: Urgent & Unimportant and  (Deadlines for things that are not goal-related)
4: non-urgent & non important.  (Waste)

From a birds-eye view, I would never plan time for a #4 activity at the expense of the others.  However, If it's 8 AM and I think I have 8 hours of time and five hours of work to do in category #1, I suddenly I lose the ability to realize that spending my first two hours on waste will generally come at the expense of planning and education when those inevitable emergencies and delays pop up.

Consider this from New Yorker book review:

"Most of the contributors to the new book agree that this peculiar irrationality stems from our relationship to time—in particular, from a tendency that economists call “hyperbolic discounting.” A two-stage experiment provides a classic illustration: In the first stage, people are offered the choice between a hundred dollars today or a hundred and ten dollars tomorrow; in the second stage, they choose between a hundred dollars a month from now or a hundred and ten dollars a month and a day from now. In substance, the two choices are identical: wait an extra day, get an extra ten bucks. Yet, in the first stage many people choose to take the smaller sum immediately, whereas in the second they prefer to wait one more day and get the extra ten bucks. In other words, hyperbolic discounters are able to make the rational choice when they’re thinking about the future, but, as the present gets closer, short-term considerations overwhelm their long-term goals"


But why do people lack the ability to prioritize in the moment?  Why do so many people allow themselves to be distracted when there is important work to be done?
Is it because we are hit from a very young age with information, media, and recreational overload? Maybe that's part of it.  But the real culprit is:  School.  Yes, School.

Now I know what those three people who read my blog regularly are saying: "John, why do you blame teachers for everything."  First, I don't.  Second, Teachers and schools are directly involved in the development of work ethic.  I don't have time to develop statistical evidence, so I'm obviously working off assumptions here, but is it that big of a leap that schools play a major role?

Consider a normal school day.  You get to school with all of your friends and distractions everywhere, and then you are corralled into a classroom.  You are designed to be loud and active, but you have to suppress your very nature and wait for recess and lunchtime.  You sit around and "learn" so that you can do work which is due at a later date to prepare for tests at a later date. (Information that will be mostly forgotten)  Most or all of your potential rewards are based on future performance.  Furthermore, most students believe that they can always make up for a poor performance or two.

Basically, students are engineered to believe that they can always make up for today's performance with a good performance tomorrow.  In many classes, they can struggle for weeks without any long term consequences.

I'm not advocating for harsh punishment at a young age, but it seems to me like this trend continues throughout public education and even into college.  In law school, you can essentially sleep through the first half of the semester and still get great grades come finals time.

Consider athletics.  You slack off in practice, you're benched for the game.  You miss practice, you're benched for the game.  You come to the game unprepared, you lose...publicly, and you might not get another chance next game.   Why do you think so many schools try to enforce academic standards with athletic penalties?   It's instant feedback, instant punishment, instant reward, which are MIA in our schools.  Students are graduating with bad habits, and some employers have given in.

You have adult men with responsibilities who will put off studying, work, sleep, or even sex to play video games.  You have countless employees who will read articles, peruse Facebook, and write blog posts (oops) when they should be working.  While threats of termination of the personal or professional relationship may motivate a person to temporarily change, I believe this bad behavior is not a result of a lack of love or duty.  It's due to a condition developed at a young age.   Your time in school as a child taught you over and over and over that now means little, and later means a lot.

We can combat this problem through immediate rewards and punishments.  Students who demonstrate preparedness in class should be free from homework assignments.  At a certain age, Students should have the opportunity to advance through classes faster if they can test out.  Students should be ranked every week and the top half should be published in order.  Each and every week is a new opportunity to shine in front of your teachers, parents, and peers.  Benefits and punishments should be specifically outlined and enforced, and benefits for short term diligence should be larger.

These are just a few examples.  I know they have problems, and I'm sure there would be countless excuses if any of these initiatives were implemented on a broad scale.

Even though the solution may be hard, the first step is admitting there is a problem... but not until you reorganize your book collection or clean out your DVR.





Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Teachers and Servers: Don't you dare talk bad about them!

I am surprised with the vigorous defenses people make when I talk negatively against teachers or servers/waiters.  I could criticize any profession aside from that of a homemaker or soldier, without receiving a passionate response, but my criticisms of teachers and waiters make even the meek write me messages in capital letters.

Why?  (Let's put aside the fact, for a moment, that I criticize teacher compensation structures, not teachers.)


Low wages?
Are you all so protective of teachers and servers because they don't make much?  Garbage men, court clerks, and bank tellers don't make much.  Produce boys at grocery stores don't make much?  Why would you protect a waiter more vigorously than a cashier?  Besides, Waiters make at least minimum wage--they have to--and teachers make as much as social workers, court clerks, and even some nurses.  Furthermore, Teachers and Waiters know how much they will be paid when they sign up.  Their base wages are basically more predictable than any other profession.

Because everyone is related to a teacher or a waiter?
Really? The entire professional should be free from criticism because you know someone?  Your Aunt or sister is a great teacher so all teachers should make twice as much?

Because they are picked on so much?
So are lawyers. People hate us.  Usually they hate us because of one isolated run-in with an attorney or based on some running joke.  But nobody defends lawyers.. My wife wouldn't even defend my profession. :)

Because people underestimate how hard the job is?
Yeah, I get it: teachers work more than 9 months a year, and waiters don't always get great tips.  I'm not sure I understand why that should save them from criticism.

Because their income potential is limited?
This one makes sense.  Although some attorneys and medical residents actually make FAR less than teachers per hour (even super teachers), those attorneys and doctors can go on to make much more.  Still though, is this a surprise?

Because they have no control?
Teacher's don't tend to open their own businesses or move to more exciting fields.  The unions and governments hold teachers down.  So this makes them blameless?  Waiters are stuck with base wages of 2.50 an hour and they can't seem to move up, but they could leave and do something else.

Because I'm not qualified to criticize?
I'm not saying I am qualified to fix the educational system, but I think I have enough experience to point out deficiencies in the system.  Besides, since when does someone have to be "qualified" before they can criticize something?  How does the old cliche` go?  I don't need to know how to sing to tell if someone is out of key? I have attended eleven schools in my life. (4 elementary schools, a "sixth-grade center", one middle school, one high school, one college, and two universities.)  I estimate I've taken classes from 60-75 teachers.  I've been involved in termination hearings for teachers with tenure.  I think I can recognize that there is a MASSIVE difference in the performance of teachers and schools and they all tend to get paid based on anything but ability.  I would think effective, hard-working teachers would be losing their minds over the current education system.
I don't think I am qualified to criticize waiters... so I don't.  But people mostly get upset when I criticize the merits of tipping in America.

I know it's probably a combination of these and other reasons, but I am impressed by the sensitivity.